Washington law

Mayor-council is a government. Council-manager is a board of directors.

Washington cities use two statutory forms. The names sound similar. The chain of command is not. The whole fight in Camas is whether the person who runs the city answers to the voters or to the council.

Watercolor of the Liberty Theatre

Current Camas

Mayor / Council / Administrator

Who is the city’s CEO?
Elected mayor

Who the public can replace
The mayor, on election day

Accountability
Pinned on one elected mayor

Day-to-day operations
City administrator under the mayor

The word “mayor”
Chief executive

Balance of power
Separate executive and legislature

Proposed

Council / Manager / Ceremonial mayor

Who is the city’s CEO?
Appointed city manager

Who the public can replace
Only the council — not the manager

Accountability
Diffused across council and a hired manager

Day-to-day operations
City manager under the council

The word “mayor”
Ceremonial council chair

Balance of power
Council hires and directs the executive

Mayor-council

Separation of powers, with a political executive

Voters elect a mayor at-large as chief administrative officer and a council as the legislature. The mayor carries out policy, appoints department heads, and in cities (not towns) has a veto the council can override. MRSC’s principles: separation of powers, political leadership, a strong central executive.

Council-manager

A board that hires the CEO

Voters elect a council. The council hires a manager to run the government. The “mayor” is a council member with ceremonial duties and no administrative authority. MRSC is explicit: the model is a business board appointing a chief executive, like a school board and superintendent. When something fails, the manager can cite council policy and council can cite operations. That spreading of blame is accountability diffusion.

Camas is already a hybrid

Like many mayor-council cities, Camas created a city administrator under the mayor — Municipal Code Chapter 2.06. That is how you get professional management without abolishing the executive the public elected. MRSC describes this hybrid as elected leadership plus professional day-to-day operations.

The proposal on the table is not “add a professional.” Camas has one. The proposal is to move hiring and replacement of that professional from the mayor to the council, and to make the mayor a gavel, not a CEO.

As of 2020, 227 of 281 Washington cities used mayor-council — 81 percent of cities, 58 percent of incorporated population.

MRSC: City and Town Forms of Government · Cities that switched, and switched back

A council does not oversee the way a mayor does

A mayor oversees the administrator because that is the mayor’s job. One elected person can give an order and answer for it.

A council does not oversee a manager that way. State law says the opposite. RCW 35A.13.120 forbids the council and its members from directing appointments or giving orders to the manager’s staff. Except to ask questions, they deal with administration only through the manager. What they keep is a board’s power: policy, the budget, and the vote to replace the manager. Between those votes, the professional makes the decisions. That is worse oversight, not the same oversight under a new title.

As of 2020, 227 of 281 Washington cities used mayor-council — 81 percent of cities, 58 percent of incorporated population. It is the oldest and still the most common form in the state, including both small towns and large cities.

MRSC: City and Town Forms of Government · Cities that switched, and switched back

Existing Evidence Does Not Show Council-Manager Cities Deliver Better Outcomes

A common argument for switching from mayor-council to council-manager is that it produces more efficient operations, stronger fiscal results, or higher-quality services. Existing research does not support that claim once size, growth, demographics, economic conditions, and service arrangements are controlled. Camas, however, uses the hybrid mayor-council-administrator form, which studies rarely differentiate from pure mayor-council systems.

A major 2015 review in Public Administration Review by Jered B. Carr found that the core claim of better management under council-manager has not been seriously demonstrated. The literature does not support systematic differences in service quality or general operational effectiveness. Washington has no controlled study isolating form of government as the cause of better fiscal health, service levels, or resident satisfaction.

Most studies compare pure mayor-council systems with pure council-manager systems. They do not cleanly test hybrid cities like Camas, which already have a professional city administrator under an elected mayor. Because Camas already has professional management, switching to pure council-manager would not primarily add professionalism; it would remove the elected CEO and place the professional under the council. Existing evidence does not show that this change produces better service, fiscal, or satisfaction outcomes.

The clearest documented difference is political accountability: under the current hybrid form, voters can replace a single elected chief executive on election day. Under council-manager, the executive is an appointed manager removable only by a majority of the council.

Jered B. Carr, “What Have We Learned about the Performance of Council-Manager Government? A Review and Synthesis of the Research,” Public Administration Review 75, no. 5 (2015): 673–689. 

Managerialism: When Professional Management Replaces Elected Authority   

Managerialism is the belief that the person who runs a city should be a trained manager, judged by professional standards, rather than a person the voters elect and can replace. Council-manager government writes that belief into the structure. The council is a board. The manager is the chief executive. Politics is supposed to stop when policy is adopted, and the rest is treated as a technical job.

That is a further step than the hybrid Camas already has. The proposal does not add an administrator under the mayor. It takes the elected executive off the ballot. The person who runs the city then answers to the council that hired him, not to the next election. 

Overcoming Managerialism: Power, Authority and Rhetoric at Work by Robert Spillane and Jean Etienne Joullié (2023)

Wikipedia: Managerialism